Are You Skinny-Fat?

are you skinny fatBefore I start writing, I want to make sure no one feels like they are being called fat. Skinny-Fat is the name given to people who are thin, but still carry around a high percentage of body fat.

Skinny-Fat, Explained

For example, let’s take two women who weigh the same, but one has a higher percentage of body fat.

Female #1 – 120 pounds 25% body fat
Female #2 – 120 pounds 15% body fat

No one is going to say that either of these women is fat. However, one of them is at a healthier body composition than the other, even though they both weigh the same.

Female # 1 is likely to be unhappy with the way she looks. Her waist, hips, and thighs are likely to be larger, and she more than likely doesn’t exercise or eat correctly. She will have very little muscle, and the body mass that she does carry around is mostly fat.

Female # 2 is going to have abs. She likely exercises every day, and more than likely, she has her nutrition dialed in. She carries around muscle and looks fit – muscle that is helping her burn more fat and look better.

Read why you need to build muscle to burn fat.

This is one of the many reasons why I tell people to stay off the scale. Both are 120 pounds, but female #2 has half the amount of fat on her body.

Read more about why you shouldn’t use the scale to gauge healthy.

How Do People Become Skinny-Fat?

There are usually 2 primary reasons why people become skinny fat.

Reason #1:

They diet, but they don’t exercise. Muscle needs stimulation to grow, especially while dieting. If you are eating below maintenance calories while dieting, and you aren’t working out, your body has no reason to hold onto its muscle. It will start to lose muscle. Will you lose weight? Yes. But not the kind of weight that you want to lose – fat.

Reason #2:

They don’t eat enough calories. Your muscle needs calories to maintain itself and grow. Muscle is highly energy intensive. It is constantly burning calories for you, even while you are sitting there watching TV. It is imperative that you do what’s necessary to hold onto it while dieting.

Eating too few calories puts your body into a highly catabolic state. When you eat too few calories, your body’s starvation mechanisms kick in, and it starts to shed what is unnecessary to maintain. Since muscle is highly calorie intensive to maintain, and it isn’t needed in large amounts to survive, your body holds onto its valuable fat reserves (energy) and rids itself of unneeded muscle.

Read more about why you’re not eating enough calories to lose weight.

So if you’ve ever wondered how someone can be skinny and fat and the same time, there you have it. A little guidance, and they (or you) can get on the right track towards achieving what you really want – fat loss.

MUST READ: The Definitive Guide for How to Lose Weight
FREE EBOOK: The 10 Forgotten Rules of Weight Loss
Print Friendly
About Tony Schober

Healthy living curator, blogger, foodie, certified personal trainer, husband, & step-dad to 3. Founder of Coach Calorie. Hates scales.

  • Gwendolyn

    This is so true. My weight HAS NOT CHANGED in ages, but people keep telling me I look slimmer. My face is slimmer, most of my clothes and looser and my boobs are disappearing! But, I have really increased my muscle tone.
    No weight change, completly different body fat percentage!

  • Coach Calorie

    Congrats Gwendolyn! I always tell people to stay off the scale. Weight is a worthless measurement unless you’re using it to calculate body fat percentage.

  • ria clarke

    This post totally describes me! I hover between 115-118 but am quite flabby, especially after 2 children. I don’t exercise regularly, only when I feel like ( I go through spurts) but am trying to be more diligent so I can tone up my flabby stomach, thighs and arms.

    • Coach Calorie

      Resistance exercise and proper diet will get you to where you want. You’ve recognized the problem, so that puts you ahead of 90% of the population.

  • Jenny Scott

    This is SO me (skinny-fat). I weigh less than I have in my life but I know that I’m not at a good body fat percentage. I need to increase my workouts and change my eating for sure. Haven’t been able to find the right motivation quite yet.

  • http://brokenwon.blogspot.com Wendy T

    I wish someone would use the word skinny in whatever context when discussing me ;)

  • Jackie

    This is kind of me. However I am so afraid to gain weight. I was 300lbs and now I am 125lbs. Everyone tells me I look to skinny. But I haven’t lost anymore weight I am just exercising on a daily basis. My concern is my diet. I am still eating around 1200 calories. I have completely changed my lifestyle eating habits. I’m not saying I don’t eat sweets I do I just limit what I eat. I cook healthier for my family and myself. I am trying to maintain my weight however I still have a lot of excess skin I would like to get rid of. Any suggestions greatly appreciated.

  • ssbokor

    I was called skinny fat once and it is the worst thing you can say to a woman!! My confidence plummeted an I quit going to the gym and gained weight,. Please use another term. That is so unkind! I was called fat all my life by my parents even though I wasn’t that big. The more people called me fat — the more weight I gained. Please quit using this term!!! I HATE it!!!

    • http://www.coachcalorie.com/ Coach Calorie

      I’m sorry you’re offended. My intention is not to offend anyone, but to help people understand what it means, and to show people that thin doesn’t always mean healthy.

      • ssbokor

        I know you didn’t mean to offend, but it does offend.

  • determined

    Yes!!! I totally agree!

  • http://www.coachcalorie.com/ Coach Calorie

    I do think that might be low, but I wouldn’t worry so much about calories right now, and instead focus on making steps to getting your diet 90% whole, nutritious foods.