This is a guest post by Deanna of My Fitness & Nutrition
Once upon a time, I was an overweight person, like most of America, lost in a sea of fitness myths, advertising, and media that constantly contradicted themselves and each other. The in-shape people simply preached, “Just eat right and exercise!” So I tried to “eat right” and “exercise”. But I was uneducated and going on only the things I thought I knew, which got me absolutely nowhere.
It’s hard enough, mentally, to have the willpower to change your diet and exercise program to be effective without having to sift through all the bad information out there. I’m here to help set you straight with the top 5 biggest fitness myths about diet and exercise, so that hopefully you can have the correct information to reach your goals.
Fitness Myths #1: You Gained Pounds of Fat This Weekend
So you had a rough weekend, or gluttonous week-long vacation, and you stepped on the scale and saw that you [GASP] GAINED 5 POUNDS! You beat yourself up, and maybe you even just decide to give up. Whoa, there….
First of all, you may have put on 5 pounds of weight. This does NOT mean you put on 5 pounds of FAT, which is the one you need to worry about. It takes 3500 calories to gain 1 pound of fat, so to gain 5 pounds of fat = 17,500 calories ON TOP OF your normal calorie intake. That is a heck of a lot of binging and while I’m not saying it can’t be done, the more likely cause of the increase on the scale is that you ate junk food, which contains lots of simple carbs, which were stored in your body as water. So you probably feel bloated and bulky, and maybe your pants are even a little tighter than normal. But the simple solution is to just get right back on your plan, drink a little extra water and lower your sodium, and within a few days you’ll drop the extra water and get right back down to where you were.
Fitness Myths #2: Strength Training Makes You Bulky or Thick
Women tend to be weary of strength training because they worry they will get too muscular or thick. Becoming lean and toned is two processes working together: building up muscle and losing fat, simultaneously.
Building muscle will help burn the fat, because muscle requires more calories to maintain. The more muscle you have, the more calories and fat you will burn just being alive (increased metabolism). Eating the right foods also makes sure that your body uses your stored fat to burn those calories rather than your muscle. It’s true what they say, “Abs are born in the kitchen.”
If you’re one of the women who worries about looking like those buff weightlifter ladies with the defined jaws and manly physiques, don’t. It’s physically impossible for us to bulk up to that level without some hormonal help, which 9 times out of 10, is exactly what you’re seeing with the bodybuilder type women that look like this. This is one of the biggest fitness myths.
Fitness Myths #3: You Can Spot Reduce Fat With Exercise
This one is probably the one of the fitness myths I see and hear most often. I was just on Pinterest this morning, and saw one person after the next post a link to 15 days to lose the flabby arms, with exercises that targeted only the arm muscles. Sigh.
As I wrote about above in Myth #2, working a muscle does not make you lose fat in that area. Working that one particular area does not make that muscle reach out and eat the fat that is covering it, nor does it make it hot so that the fat around it melts. You can’t burn specific calories in one spot; our bodies just don’t work that way. As I am sure you have all noticed in your own bodies, we store fat in different ways, which are genetically predisposed. What that means is, if our mothers stored their fat in their bellies, we’re likely to also. Does this mean you’re doomed to have a big belly like your mom? No! It just means that if you both eat more calories than you burn, you’re likely to notice the fat building up in the same places. If this has happened to you, and you’ve put on weight, you have to lose the fat all over to melt it in your trouble area too. You must adhere to a healthy lifestyle to lose your muffin top with a combination of a healthy diet and exercise, so that your body uses its fat stores as fuel. It will burn that troublesome spot eventually, with some patience.
Fitness Myths #4: You Need Long Workouts to Exercise Effectively
The fact is, it’s not the amount of time that you workout that makes your exercise effective, but instead, it’s the INTENSITY. A high intensity workout is short but more effective than a long cardio session.
High intensity interval training, or HIIT, is a form of exercise where you push yourself to your absolute max for a short period of time, followed by a short period of recovery…this is an interval. Doing this type of exercise for just 20 minutes a day is all you need to burn ridiculous amounts of calories and build an athletic body.
When you do low-intensity workouts, such as walking, you burn extra calories beginning when you start and ending when you stop. Let’s say you just burned 150 calories walking or doing yoga. Eat two pieces of bread, and your entire hour was a waste. With high-intensity workouts, you use carbohydrates to fuel your workout, and then burn fat for hours after you finish exercising, for many reasons. The body is put under so much stress during HIIT that it burns calories just trying to get itself back to normal (restoring depleted carbohydrates, re-oxygenating the blood, etc). It also builds muscle as you work, and the more muscle you have, the more calories you will burn just resting, because muscle requires more calories to maintain than fat.
When you’re working at maximum intensity, you will be breathing hard, not be able to speak, your heart will be pounding, and you’ll likely be sweating a ton.
HIIT can be applied to all types of exercise-from running to bike riding to weightlifting to body weight exercise.
Fitness Myths #5: You Lose Fat Burning More Calories Than You Eat
So not true. You will lose WEIGHT by burning more calories than you eat. And if being “skinny fat” with no muscle tone and a jiggly body is what you’re after, then by all means eat 1200 calories of cookies every day and burn 1300 with your own metabolism and a walk. You’ll lose weight on the scale, in the form of precious muscle. Your body will use your muscle as its fuel source before it uses fat, because we are programmed genetically to do so (the body instinctively holds onto fat in case of famine). But I think most of us can agree that skinny fat isn’t sexy, healthy or desirable. Not only will you be jiggly, but also you’ll feel bad with less energy, and you’ll be at a higher risk for all sorts of diseases and illness, including cancer.
To lose fat, you need to eat fat-burning, nutritious foods that support your exercise program. You need protein to build muscle, and healthy carbohydrates and fats for energy and brain function. A healthy diet will make you feel more clear-headed, give you more energy for your workouts as well as everyday life, make you feel full and satisfied, and, planned correctly, will encourage your body to build muscle and use its fat stores for energy, thus melting that fat away.
Losing weight by losing muscle actually decreases metabolism, which will limit how much weight you can actually lose. As I’ve said, muscle requires more calories just to simply maintain than fat does. Increasing your muscle mass, therefore, means an increased metabolism. Simple.
A little education can go a long way when it comes to fitness and nutrition. Having the right information is the key to long-term success in your program, and will help you to break past the barriers to a healthy lifestyle.











Twitter: FFT_UK
says:
Hey Deanna – Fitness Myths #2: Strength Training Makes You Bulky or Thick really annoys me. So many women avoid strength training and stick solely to cardio because of this myth. It’s so deeply ingrained that even when you tell them the truth a lot don’t want to hear it and refuse to train with weights.
Tom Parker recently posted..Alcohol And Fitness – Can The 2 Go Hand In Hand?
I think some of these myths are so believed, like the second one, that people don’t even think they could be wrong. Who knows how this is hurting someone’s fitness plan or diet?
cole recently posted..Celtic Complexion
Very true Cole. I’ve heard myth # 2 so many times that you’d think people were allergic to weights
Great post, Deanna. I particularly like myth #1, because we just got back from a week long vacation. I’m feeling a little icky now, but I’m not beating myself up over it. The first thing I did when I got home was go grocery shopping so I’d have healthy foods around the house again.
I was so encouraged to read Myth #1! Even though I’ve learned that a pound of fat is 3500 calories somehow I never put it together than when I fluctuate 3-4 pounds in one or two days that is can’t possibly be fat pounds. I used to get really discouraged when I would go up like that in one day but now I just take it in stride. It’s so helpful to know because often when you get discouraged, your resolve plumits which can lead to poor choices. If you know that fluctuations are a normal part of weight/fitness, you won’t get discouraged and won’t let it affect your determination to make healthy choices no matter what the scale says.
glad to see someone setting the record straight!
Well all of this is new territory for me. I used to be in much better shape.
When my daughter passed away after a valiant fight with brain cancer, I became depressed and sedentary. I’m still both, but am thinking and trying to change that now. I’m some 30 pounds heavier now. My problem in reading all that you wrote is trying to digest it and figure out what it means and where to go from here.
I need a book “The Dummies Guide to Getting From the Sofa to Life Again”.
I can read number one as a reason to not get down on myself when the numbers look bad…kwim?
For me it starts with awareness and reading here, other places, and thinking and behaving differently are all places for me to be now.
Twitter: sheisstrong
says:
Hi Wendy, I am so, so sorry about your daughter…words just don’t do it justice and having 3 kids of my own, I cannot imagine.
And certainly I can understand becoming depressed and sedentary, which is why I think it’s amazing that you’re making an effort to get moving and healthy.
My dad actually had a brain stem tumor, although not cancerous, it was devastating to his motor skills when they tried to remove it. While I did spend a good amount of time depressed and miserable, I tried to channel that into motivation for me to keep myself healthy for my kids and family. It sounds so cliche just typing it, but I can’t tell you how many times, when I’ve been in the middle of a tough run or workout, I’ve pushed myself through it by thinking of how much he would love to be able just to walk now, and I do it for him.
Take it all in baby steps. Learning is a great first step. Do what you can every single day and never, ever beat yourself up when you can’t. Just keep going!
Hugs,
Deanna
Deanna recently posted..Recipe-Egg and Turkey Sausage Frittatas
I just found your website, and I am loving reading through it all!
I walk 3x a week, have a personal trainer once a week, and do pilates once a week. I know the pilates and personal trainer are great for me (weightlifting mostly and core exercises) but is the walking a waste of time? We walk for 4-5 miles at a good clip, burning 500-600 calories in the hour. I thought this cardio in the morning “revved up” my metabolism and helped me burn more calories throughout the day?
Amy
It’s definitely not a waste of time. Cardio first thing in the morning will get your metabolism going, but as far as burning more calories throughout the day, walking won’t do much for you. I wrote about what you’re seeking in this article – Harnessing the Afterburn Effect with EPOC Training