Your Body Composition – How You Became You

what is body compositionYou’ve probably heard the term body composition used in the fitness and diet world many many times, but do you fully understand what body composition means?

Body composition is the makeup of a human body. For our purposes, we’ll categorize this makeup into body fat versus lean body mass, which is anything that is not fat: water, bone, muscle, etc.  This can be measured in many ways, but the most common and easiest way to measure is with skin calipers and skin-fold measurements.  Let’s say you have 35% body fat, this means that your body is composed of more than 1/3 fat.

But body composition is not all about fat.  Let’s take a look at four general categories of body fat and muscle composition, and how you can either achieve or avoid them.

High Fat, Low Muscle Body Composition


The person with this body composition is generally pretty out of shape. They likely don’t exercise, and have eaten enough additional calories to put on and store extra fat. Due to this lack of exercise, they have very little muscle tone underneath the fat on their bodies. Because muscle requires more calories to maintain, the person with low muscle tone also has a lower metabolism and will likely have trouble dieting to get the extra fat off. Their appearance is anywhere from heavy to obese. To gain a healthy body composition, these individuals need to decrease their calorie intake through a healthy diet and exercise, and should focus on increasing their muscle mass through strength training to increase metabolism.

High Fat, High Muscle Body Composition


Have you ever seen someone who appeared “thick” or “bulky”? Maybe they work out and have muscle tone, but they also have a high amount of fat that covers the muscle. An example might be a bodybuilder who is going through the “bulking” phase, or a football linebacker – both of which eat a high calorie diet to put on muscle but also put on fat at the same time. Many times, women who begin working out without changing their diet will start to “bulk up” and stop working out because of it. If this is you and you’d like a leaner appearance, keep working out, but focus on what you are eating. A healthy, clean diet is essential to maintaining the beautiful muscle while melting away the layer of fat that covers it. Focus on protein, vegetables, fruit, and healthy fats at every meal.

Low Fat, Low Muscle Body Composition


A person with this body makeup will look anywhere from average size to thin to skeletal. Maybe he or she appears thin with clothes on, but is jiggly underneath, or “skinny fat“. While they may be happy with their weight, they may be unhappy with their appearance. An extreme case would be someone who appears overly thin; think heroin-chic supermodels. This person probably doesn’t exercise or maybe focuses on only cardio (which burns calories but can actually burns muscle as well, thus over time lowering metabolism). Their diet may be average to unhealthy, but they don’t eat many calories. For a healthier body composition, this body type should focus on adding strength training so that they will increase their muscle tone, while eating healthier foods with enough calories to support their exercise routine.

Low Fat, High Muscle Body Composition


This is the body composition that you will achieve if you strength train, stay active, and eat a nutritious diet. Your muscle tone will show because a) you built it through strength training and b) you melted the fat so it can be seen. This person will have anywhere from a healthy, toned appearance to downright ripped. The more muscle you build, the bigger you will appear (ladies, don’t worry…you won’t get too big unless you take hormones/steroids…we’re just not made that way) and the less fat you have, the more defined your muscles will look. The person with this body composition will also have a higher metabolism because of their large amount of muscle content, and will have more room for error and a higher calorie demand in their diets once they reach this phase.

While I’ve simplified the appearance of body composition into these 4 categories, the truth is that there is a large range and endless combinations in each one. How you eat and train will determine how your body will be composed, so it’s essential for each individual to assess their needs based on what the end result should be. It’s also important to remember that genetics play a part in body composition, too. If you’re genetically pre-dispositioned to a certain shape, no exercise will change that…just like no exercise will make you taller or shorter. Your skeletal and muscular makeup is unique to you, so focus on being the best YOU.

Why Weight is Only a Small Piece of the Puzzle

Now maybe you understand a little bit better why we drill into your heads that weight and the number on the scale don”t matter. The people falling into the first two categories may be at a similar weight, but the person with more muscle is going to have a higher metabolism and healthier body composition. The people falling in the last two categories may also have a similar weight. Low fat, high muscle bodies may actually weigh MORE than the low fat low muscle ones, but have the toned, lean look and higher metabolism.  This is because 1 pound of muscle is much smaller than 1 pound of fat.

What body composition category do you fall in? What is your ideal body composition and how are you working to attain it?

MUST READ: The Definitive Guide for How to Lose Weight
FREE EBOOK: The 10 Forgotten Rules of Weight Loss
Print Friendly
About Deanna Schober

Deanna Schober is the owner of IntelliFit Coaching, a PN certified nutrition consultant, mom of 3, wife, coffee lover, former overweight processed food junkie who learned to love healthy living and self-care.

  • http://www.truth2beingfit.com Jody – Fit at 54

    I am 4! :-) AND I will be 55 this November. I love to lift & love muscles. I do cardio too, core, stretch & it is helping me stay strong as I age!

    • Deanna Schober

      This is my goal too! Fitness and diet are truly a fountain of youth. Good for you.

  • Debbie

    Of course I strive for 4 but tend to be more like 3. I have the skinny fat Asian woman frame, small, 100 lbs. with naturally high % of body fat and difficulty building muscle. Strength training definitely helps but it is difficult to achieve the lean body type without also following a super clean diet. Which of course I want to do but it’s difficult. Great article, love the photo examples.

    • Deanna Schober

      Thanks Debbie, that’s the hard part for me too is the clean diet but you’re right, it’s mandatory for most. Glad you enjoyed the article.

  • Birdie

    I believe I’m a 4! I’m almost 40, have had 6 kids, and not only do I work out…I play roller derby. I have some work to do still, eating more clean is one goal. However, with my activity level and the fact that I wear a size Sm or 3 & 5′s at 139 pounds….I’m pretty sure I’m a 4 :)

    • Deanna Schober

      That’s awesome Birdie!

  • barbara finch

    thanks for an interesting lesson on bodytypes.
    I am undoubtedly bodytype #1
    I used to be bodytype#4 until a few years ago..
    I have no idea what to do in the way of exercise to get to #4 again
    I am doing fine on the diet, but at my age, with 2 heart stents, and 40 kilos overweight, it’s a delicate matter.
    Tell you what I am trying: walks for 20 minutes a day, walking as if I am late for a train: starting back at the gym doing light easy 45 minute workouts like bodystep, not ready for weights, ready to start cycling in the gym but not on the road, think I would break the bike. just bought a tennis racquet and start next week, 3 hours a week, and have been told to get into the pool at the gym just to get zen.- laps and aqua class.
    you’re the golden person with the info, what’s missing from this recipe?
    love
    Barb
    PS don’t ever stop, you might actually wake us all up one day!

    • Deanna Schober

      Hi Barbara, you mention all of your exercise but you didn’t mention your diet, so I’m wondering if that might be the missing ingredient for you. Try to eat lean meats and proteins, lots of veggies and fruits, healthy fats and cut out all processed foods. Do this 80-90% of the time and I bet you’ll see big results.

  • Jennifer Jessel

    WOW – the article was good, but I have to admit what got me the most was the picture of the “fat” and the “muscle” – that, for me, was quite the eye opener.

    I have just started to change my lifestyle and put to use all the things that I know are good and healthy for me,,I know I have a long way to go, but at least I have started. I am going to keep this article and I will refer to it from time to time, if only to look at the fat/muscle picture for a quick reality check!

    Thanks for publishing this!

    Jennifer

    • Deanna Schober

      You’re welcome Jennifer, good luck on your journey!

  • Nikki

    Im 42 have four children and have lost over 45 kilos. Hard work and determination is the key. I love working out strength and cardio. I have toned up and no sagging or excess skin. Girls if I can do it anyone can. :-)

    • Deanna Schober

      Nikki I say that to people about me all the time ;) If I can do it anyone can!

  • http://debroby.com Deb

    Sadly, at the moment I’m a #2. Was a #4 3 years ago, but 2 years of injury and surgery has taken its toll. Still don’t have the metabolic conditioning recovered from the last surgery.

    But I’m strong and working out and know things will change with time.

    (BTW, I’m 60. and almost a year out from a total hip replacement. but will be in my first powerlifting competition in November.)

    • Deanna Schober

      Deb good luck at your competition! That is awesome.

  • bobbie

    Thanks for this article, I always enjoy and learn from your posts. I am a runner, and currently I’m training for a marathon. I am no longer a two, but maybe more of a three than a four . I have serious muscle tone in my legs, but my belly is sill there. I am 5’7, and I weigh 165. I wear a size 10. I am 42. I do not have time for weight with two jobs, three kids and two plus hours a day devoted to running. Recently, I have started really focusing on making every calorie count, and I’ve seen some improvement. I need my overall body weight to be lighter, though….and this running 35-40 miles/wk makes me so hungry, lol.

    • Kelsey

      Bobbie – stop all that running! It lowers your metabolism, that’s why you still have a belly! You NEED to lift weights and strength train to get to the size and body type you want. Try reading Female Body Breakthrough by Rachael Cosgrove.

  • Janalee

    I am between a 2 and a 4. I have lost a ton of baby weight (almost 65 pounds) with only 10 to go in order to reach pre-baby status. I have been losing inches over the past 6 months but not really weight. I’m tightening up my diet and training for a new obsession- obstacle course racing- to try and get to the goal weight/size. Great, succinct article. My favorite is the comparison of muscle and fat. I always seem to forget that part!

  • Carly Y

    Hello,

    I have been following your site and reading everything you post for a couple of months now… I read every article and I guess I am one of those people who wants to hear something new… Something I don’t already know! The truth is, I am a doctor and I am a former highly competitive international athlete. I have many years under my belt with experience in sport and in nutrition. I understand body composition, I understand exercise, and honestly, I understand absolutely everything you’ve ever posted! Only a few years ago, I finally had to give up competing in my sport because my career has obviously become overwhelming. So here is my story now…

    I used to be in great shape – 6-pack and all. I had great muscle definition and minimal body fat, no embarrassment about my body or any pudge, and I had no fear of ever losing that body. Like almost ALL former competitive athletes, the transition from living my sport, to living “real” life has not been an easy one. My body changed quickly and unexpectedly, and I became depressed. Not to mention the stress of my job… Three years ago this major change in my life took place, and I still can’t get my life and my mind back on track. I have gained 30 pounds and I have no consistency in my lifestyle, in my diet, in my exercise, and in my motivation. I am still suffering depression and high stress and anxiety. I have my good days when I hit the gym and lift heavy and go to a spin class, and then the next day I might decide I don’t care, and I’ll binge on junk and not get off my butt.

    I don’t question at all how I got to where I am today; I am not surprised that I don’t lose weight or maintain my muscle – because I cannot find the motivation. I read all your ideas for motivation and really….. nothing sounds like a good enough reason to me. What I struggle with is finding how to fix it. I take anti-depressants but I hope I only have to do it until I get over this bump-in-the-road that seems to be interrupting my entire being. Most of my stress and depression I believe stems from my body image and self-image… I know I am not the person I used to be, but I can’t figure out how to be OK with that. I don’t WANT to be OK with that.

    There is this huge part of me that believes I can still look the way I once did without being a pro-athlete. But there is that voice in my head telling me “Carly, you just don’t have it in you anymore. Carly, where are you going to find the energy for that? And on days that you don’t feel like it, where are you going to find the motivation inside of you for it?”

    I am not in love with myself, in fact, I hate myself. I cannot afford a personal trainer on a daily basis to kick my ass into the gym where I know I WANT to be, where I am actually happy. You’d think that alone would make me want to be there on a daily basis. But it’s not. And alas, I find myself battling the same emotional battle with myself on a daily basis. I know you’re not going to have any revelations for me… but maybe you have something you can share with me or some help to offer…?

    Carly Y

    P.S. When I started typing this I didn’t intend at all to spill all my emotional baggage all over the place. I don’t know how or why I did, so I apologize and I hope it doesn’t offend.

    • Jennifer Jessel

      OK – that sounded so much like I started to cry at my desk !!!

      I could feel your pain, much like it was someone looking straight through all of my struggles too. You wrote with such raw emotion and honesty. I bet it did you a world of good being able to write it all down for someone,,,,anyone to read,,,,just to know that you are NOT alone.

      Believe me, though I may be the only one who has written a response – I am telling you that there are SO many of “us” – ,,,yes “you” out there – probably too many to even count – LOL.

      You are human and I bet an awesome DR too. In my struggle I am learning to love myself again,,,,,and I wish you all the best as you do the same.

      Jennifer

    • sally

      Carly, this is just a thought…….. you don’t mention what the big issue was, and thats understandable, but have you thought about becoming a personal trainer? that way you would be in the gym where you love to be, and have free access to the equipment into the bargain.
      Secondly, with your medical skills, why not go into complementary healthcare, this way you would earn good money still, but part time, so you could do both jobs part time and feel fulfilled …………also working out to get your much loved body back :)
      Something to think about, and anti depressants usually make a person feel crap anyway, I know I’ve been there. Try some cognitive therapy instead.

    • Stephane11

      Carly, I was in the same place you were last year, but not a professional athlete. I used to be very athletic but over the last I would say decade, kids and life got in the way. I am on the verge of divorce from a partner with bipolar disorder and I just have been focused on my kids and this disease that highly affects my family. I am a VERY busy real estate agent having to drive my business daily. I’ve worked myself back into shape over the past 11 months. The BEST thing I’ve accomplished, is regaining my power over my life. And that has led to so many positive effects in my life. My suggestion is to maybe buddy up with someone who you can use as an accountability partner for exercise; someone who can help boost your motivation when you don’t have it. I have to agree with Jennifer below. YOU are not alone. So many of us struggle. I did for so many years. But I forced myself to pull myself out of the hole and now, I am a transformed me inside and out. Love and luck to you.

  • Tina

    I’m a former #1 who’s well on her way to becoming a #4! I lost more than 90 pounds and have been maintaining for six months and counting. Body’s getting better every day!

  • sally

    Ok this is a weight issue you probably never came accross before:
    I workout and do weights, am taking up yoga as of tomorrow too, I eat organic very nutritious diet, I am 54 and female, just hitting menopause, over the last 2 years despite all of the above I have gained 14lbs and its not muscle its fat! I had an underactive thyroid but have now got that re balanced.
    So I asked my kinesiologist why……………a bit of muscle testing later, and heres the biggy!!!
    I am keeping the fat as my sub consious mind wants me to hold onto it as protection from emotional stress in my relationship ( one which I cannot yet leave ). This is why women lose weight after divorce. All makes sense.
    Since I have tried everything else it must be right, just thought I’d share this in case anyone else is working hard but getting nowhere whereas before they were.

  • Annie

    Not sure if it is possible, but I would have to say I am between #2 and #3. I don’t have a lot of fat, but there seems to be a cushion of it over my upper arms (there are muscles under there) and over my lower abdomen and upper thigh area). I am almost 51, post menopausal, mostly vegetarian (no red meats for sure), eat healthy, run almost every day, lift weights every 2-3 days and bike 10 miles every few days (sometimes in addition to running and playing a set of tennis). I initially lost 35 lbs and kept if off for almost 2 years, but now it is slowly adding back despite my best efforts to keep up with this time consuming and very active life style. At one point I weighed 153 lbs, got down to 118 and am now back to 125. I am 5’4″ tall. I would love some words of wisdom here. I felt the best weighing between 18-20 lbs.

  • http://www.coachcalorie.com/ Deanna Schober

    Yes, exactly. Muscle is more dense so the same amount in pounds takes up much less space, therefore you’ll notice a difference in the size clothes you’re wearing even if the scale has not changed (or might even go up!)